EDITORIAL DESKHOW WE PUBLISH
AI can accelerate research. It cannot own the judgment.
City Atlas Club editorial standards for AI-assisted drafts, sources, human review, corrections, ratings, and commercial independence.
Last updated · 20 July 2026
01HOW WE PUBLISH
Our publication standard
We publish two deliberately separate layers. A source-backed city reference may be indexable when it gives a useful, traceable snapshot of stable comparison fields such as population, coordinates, elevation, time zone, classification, and nearby cities. It must also state what those fields cannot prove and link readers to the underlying sources.
A city reference is not a finished guide, a claim of personal experience, or permission to generate a route. Attraction recommendations and planner-ready status require the stricter place-by-place, three-language editorial and source gate. Scaling the reference catalog never bypasses that gate.
02HOW WE PUBLISH
AI-assisted, visibly labeled
AI may help summarize source material, propose structure, translate an approved draft, or generate alternatives for an editor to compare. It may not invent first-hand experience, pretend to have visited a place, or turn uncertain information into a confident claim. Published pages that use this workflow display an AI-assisted label.
Human review checks whether the recommendation is specific, whether translations preserve the same meaning, whether sources support the factual layer, and whether the page repeats generic phrasing found elsewhere in the atlas.
03HOW WE PUBLISH
Sources and fast-changing facts
Attraction pages include a source ledger and a source-checked date. We favor official websites for admission rules and access notices, and open knowledge projects for stable identity, geography, and media provenance. Wikipedia may provide useful context, but it is not treated as the sole authority for a fast-changing operational claim.
Prices, opening hours, transport timetables, border rules, weather, accessibility arrangements, and safety notices can change without warning. We either omit them, qualify them with a date, or point to an official source. Readers should always recheck live details before departure.
04HOW WE PUBLISH
Corrections and updates
Readers can send corrections from the community form or by email. We review the cited evidence, update the page when warranted, and refresh the visible checked date for meaningful factual reviews. Minor style edits do not receive a misleading freshness date.
05HOW WE PUBLISH
Ratings, contributors, and commercial separation
Votes and place ratings are traveler signals. We use abuse prevention and moderation, and we do not sell positive ratings. Community submissions remain pending until reviewed. Advertising, memberships, press invitations, or affiliate commissions do not guarantee coverage and do not purchase a ranking.